Saint Monkey, by Jacinda Townsend

Saint Monkey
By Jacinda Townsend
W.W. Norton & Company
Four stars
Reviewed by Jessica Gribble

I scrawled a note in the front cover of Saint Monkey: “Makes me feel like my love is precarious.” That doesn’t sound so good, except that it perfectly encapsulates the author’s abilities. Jacinda Townsend is a wonderful writer who makes you feel all kinds of complicated emotions. The main characters—Audrey and Caroline (Pookie)—start out as two young black girls in rural Kentucky. The girls are best friends with a thread of animosity running between them. The trauma of death in their families both unites and divides them. When Audrey tries to comfort Pookie after her mother’s death, she says: “Don’t think you know anything about what I’m feeling, just because your daddy died in some war. Your daddy died, but you wasn’t living every day in the same house with the person what killed him…. And my name ain’t Pookie. My mama named me Caroline.”

Pookie is more charismatic than good looking. Audrey describes her: “He didn’t notice me at all, and it salted up the difference between us. Tortoise-shell glasses, shit-colored wool stockings, a head full of high-flown literature, and hair that never grows longer than two marcels on a bumper, is what I’ve got. Two different bloods don’t meet up in my face and explode there: I’m not capable of riling up some minister enough that he starts quoting scripture at me.”

As they grow up, Audrey manages to escape to New York City thanks to her gifted piano playing. She joins a jazz group and learns about love, racism, sexism, and the constraints of work. Caroline stays home, attending church, trying to reign in her natural sarcasm, and selling makeup. Audrey writes Caroline letters, telling her everything, though Caroline almost never responds. They interpret each other’s thoughts and actions long distance, feeling connected to the core, frustrated, and envious.

As women, they’re joined in despair and the occasional delight. “And I remembered back when I’d of had Audrey to come over and share this all with, all my grief and all my wanting, and you know I’d never tell Audrey this now, but it was a time I loved her something terrible…. I knew I’d loved her better than I’d loved my own self. But she grew off and left me…. And even though it’s been a long time happening, she’s such a force she done broke my heart without even meaning to.”

I found Saint Monkey a bit hard to get into because the characters are so far removed from my own experience and because the narration alternates from one girl to the other. Audrey and Caroline think very much the same—often about each other—which is occasionally confusing. However, Townsend made my heart feel things my mind couldn’t easily understand: Audrey and Caroline’s panicked desire to flee the past, their deep yearning to find love against the odds.

Whether or not readers feel at home in this story, they’re sure to be enraptured by the language. Townsend has such a gift for it; her descriptions not only illuminate the people and landscapes they’re describing, they all come with an emotional core. “I closed my eyes and saw, on the backs of my eyelids, the coal-pregnant mountains and their ceiling of sky, the women of Queen Street crucifying their laundry with wooden clothespins. All the tender things that raised me, the things that made me more than a poor girl passing by someone’s sitting room.” In fact, there’s so much emotion in this book, it can be overwhelming. You could read it again and again and always find something new that matters.